Traditionally, a surrender ceremony was accompanied by the honors of war. 64 that is party to a non-international armed conflict, targeting decisions must be guided by the standards set by international human rights law, which means that states must make all reasonable efforts to communicate to their enemies the offer of surrender before they can be directly targeted. In essence, then, whether the discarding of weapons (where a person is in possession of weapons) and placing hands above the head or waving a white flag constitute an effective method of expressing an intention to surrender boils down to whether such conduct is supported by state practice. Thus, the test imposed by international humanitarian law is whether a reasonable combatant operating in those circumstances would have been expected to discern the offer of surrender. In short, while international humanitarian law permits parties to an armed conflict to attack (and kill) enemies, even where they are not engaging in threatening behaviour (and assuming they are not hors de combat), international human rights law permits a state to use force only where it is necessary and proportionate in the circumstances prevailing at the time.Footnote (Same book as CIVIC, Saint Nicholas Bible, Queen Elizabeth Bible except King James Epiphany only has Jewish & Christian Canada, Code of Conduct for CF Personnel (Office of the Judge Advocate General 2001) r 5 para 3. 81 46 and gives no conclusive answer as to what human rights law requires of government authorities using force against fighters.Footnote Polybius, The Histories, Vol VI, Book 36 (William Roger Paton tr, Loeb Classical Library 1927). This is the only meaning that the white flag possesses in the law of armed conflict The display of a white flag means only that one party is asked whether it will receive a communication from the other. Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (entered into force 28 January 1980) 1155 UNTS 331, art 31(3)(b). 9 But in wars against outsiders, infidels, or barbarians, the West had inherited a brutal legacy from the Romans which they termed bellum romanum, or guerre mortellle, a conflict in which no holds were barred and all those designated as enemy, whether bearing arms or not, could be indiscriminately slaughtered: Michael Howard, Constraints on Warfare in Howard, Andreopoulos and Shulman (n 12) 1, 3. At present, 168 States are party to Additional Protocol I and 164 States to Additional Protocol II,this still places the 1977 Additional Protocols among the most widely accepted legal instruments in the world. This view is also endorsed by the ICRC, which explains that [t]he law of armed conflict does not prohibit attacks on retreating enemy forces. It also grants the right to proper medical treatment and care. The first convention covers soldiers wounded on the battlefield, the second covers sailors wounded and. (3) Have the persons surrendering unconditionally submitted themselves to the authority of their captor? Liivoja, Rain, Chivalry Without a Horse: Military Honour and the Modern Law of Armed Conflict in Liivoja, Rain and Saumets, Andres (eds), The Law of Armed Conflict: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives (Tartu University Press 25 Maritime Delimitation and Territorial Questions between Qatar and Bahrain, Merits [2001] ICJ Rep 40, [205]. Put differently, there is a pressing military need to target them directly. Have persons who are attempting to surrender engaged in a positive act which clearly indicates that they no longer intend to directly participate in hostilities? The various meanings of the flag were later codified in the Hague and Geneva Conventions of the 19th and 20th centuries. 84. Nations party to the Convention may not use torture to extract information from POWs. Those who believe it will begin preparations to defend themselves against Islam. Christian knights were therefore relieved of any obligation to accept offers of surrender by non-Christian combatants.Footnote An interesting incident came to light in October 2010 as a result of classified US military logs being published by the whistle-blower website Wikileaks.Footnote 15 62 Green, Leslie, The Contemporary Law of Armed Conflict (Manchester University Press r.j.buchan@sheffield.ac.uk. The Oxford Manual of 1880, a non-binding document produced by the Institute of International Law, explained that it was prohibited to injure or kill an enemy who has surrendered at discretion or is disabled, and to declare in advance that quarter will not be given, even by those who do not ask it for themselves.Footnote In the context of an international armed conflict, Article 40 of Additional Protocol I explains that it is prohibited to order that there shall be no survivors. The 1st Marine Division and its 4,000 attached U.S. Army forces and British Royal Marines, in the famous 1950 march out of the Chosin Reservoir in North Korea, fighting outnumbered by a 4:1 margin, turned its retreat into a battle in which it defeated the 20th and 26th Chinese Armies trying to annihilate it. 51 More often than not, however, the principles of military necessity and humanity run into conflict, prompting the law in opposite directions. 110. At first the principle of humanity was used more generally to re-orientate the jurisprudential basis of European societies away from notions of divine right and religious privilege towards the values of equality, tolerance and justice. [A] soldier who fights to the very last possible moment assumes certain risks. Without a legal guarantee that they will not be made the object of attack once they have laid down their weapons and submitted themselves to the authority of their enemy, there would be no incentive for those persons engaged in hostilities to surrender and fights to the death would invariably ensue, thereby prolonging armed conflict and fuelling unnecessary violence and suffering. 12 79 It also included the prohibition of scientific experiments on POWs in response to the torture exacted on prisoners by German and Japanese doctors. Similarly, the Dominican Republic's Military Manual accepts that once a white flag is waved this signals an intent to surrender and the opposing force must cease firing from that moment: The enemy soldier may reach a point where he would rather surrender than fight. France's Manual on the Law of Armed Conflict explains that [a]n intention to surrender must be clearly expressed; by raising hands, throwing down weapons or waving a white flag.Footnote who possess a continuous combat function.Footnote A consensus was growing that, although war might still be a necessary element in international politics it should be waged, so far as possible, with humanity: Howard (n 24) 6. Where a valid offer of surrender is communicated to an opponent, there is a legal obligation upon the opponent to accept that offer and to refrain from making surrendered persons the object of attack. Twenty-six countries ratified the Conventions in the early 1990s, largely in the aftermath of the break-up of the Soviet Union, Czechoslovakia and the former Yugoslavia. 115, One final question remains. Additional Protocol II (n 49) art 13(1). Unlike international armed conflicts, the law of non-international armed conflict does not expressly define the concept of civilian notwithstanding the fact that treaty law applicable to non-international armed conflict uses the term civilian on a number of occasions.Footnote [The opponent] may not refuse an offer of surrender when communicated, but that communication must be made at a time when it can be received and properly acted upon an attempt to surrender in the midst of a hard-fought battle is neither easily communicated nor received. The rule of surrender does not require the opposing force to detain surrendered persons as prisoners of war (although they can if they wish). Attacking persons who are recognized as hors de combat is prohibited. 40 [10], False surrender is a type of perfidy in the context of war. Nevertheless, available state practice, in conjunction with the wider theoretical context within which the rule of surrender operates, can be used to make general inferences and to draw tentative conclusions as to the meaning of this rule under international humanitarian law. More specifically, questions arise as to the type of conduct that signals an intention to surrender. 1981) 50910Google Scholar. Meron, Theodor, The Humanization of Humanitarian Law (2000) 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44. The rationale underlying this rule can be explained on the basis that where it is discernible that persons have parachuted from an aircraft in distress and are not engaging in hostile acts, this is regarded as a form of positive conduct that signals that they no longer represent a threat to military security and thus there is no military necessity to directly target them. 57 3. 91 See generally British officer shocked by treatment of prisoners as 'oriental cattle' Owen Bowcott @ owenbowcott Thu 2 Jan 2003 20.58 EST US troops guarding communist captives in the Korean War violated the. For instance, in practice, the white flag has come to indicate surrender if displayed by individual soldiers or a small party in the course of an action.Footnote They protect people who do not take part in the fighting (civilians, medics, aid workers) and those who can no longer fight (wounded, sick and shipwrecked troops, prisoners of war). Many bands took no prisoners, not even children or young women. Combatants are assumed to be constantly directly participating in hostilities and are incontrovertibly permissible objects of attack.Footnote Last updates June 10, 2019 by Krystyna Blokhina, International Committee for the Red Cross and Red Crescent, 1952 Commentary on the Geneva Conventions, Geneva Convention for the Amelioration of the Condition of the Wounded and Sick in Armed Forces in the Field, of 12 August 1949, Geneva Convention for the Amelioration of the Condition of Wounded, Sick and Shipwrecked Members of Armed Forces at Sea, of 12 August 1949, Geneva Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, of 12 August 1949, Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, of 12 August 1949, Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts, of 8 June 1977, Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts, of 8 June 1977, Reference Guide to the Geneva Conventions, List of Nations Ratifying or are Otherwise Party to the Geneva Conventions and/or Protocols, ICL Practice Relating to Rule 157, Jurisdiction over War Crimes, Category: International, Transnational, and Comparative Law, Geneva Conventions and their additional protocols, Disputes arising under the Conventions or the Protocolsare settled by courts of the member nations (Article 49 of Convention I) or by international. 2. In fact, a number of states expressly reject the contention that the waving of a white flag is constitutive of surrender. It allows for the prosecution of the intentional starvation of civilians as a method of warfare as such, but also for "depriving them of objects indispensable to their survival, including wilfully impeding relief supplies as provided for under the Geneva Conventions." United Nations | International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals UN IRMCT. It is not just a matter of whether he "immediately surrendered""clearly expressing an intention to surrender" is only one of three conditions under this rule. Its full respect is required. The leaders of the surrendering group negotiate privileges or compensation for the time, expense and loss of life saved by the victor through the stopping of resistance. For a discussion of the legal framework relating to parlementaires see All in all, the point is that even if an offer of surrender is validly extended under international humanitarian law, if that offer cannot reasonably be discerned in the circumstances then, from the perspective of the opposing force, the threat represented by the enemy remains and the principle of military necessity continues to justify their direct targeting. 85 Civilians enjoy protection from direct targeting under international humanitarian law but can be made the object of attack during such time as they directly participate in hostilities.Footnote 91 Merriam-Webster defines "surrender" as "the action of yielding one's person or giving up the possession of something especially into the power of another", and traces the etymology to the Middle English surrendre, from French sur- or sus-, suz "under" + rendre "to give back";[1] this in turn is defined by the University of Michigan Middle English Dictionary as meaning "The giving up of an estate, a grant of land, or an interest in property to the person who holds the right to it", or, in law, "the relinquishing of letters patent to the king", or "the giving back or return of something". This conclusion may be different in a scenario where a commander has his or her enemy pinned down and the enemy decides to surrender but, for various reasons (such as distance between the respective parties, inimical terrain, inclement weather), the offer of surrender is not immediately apparent to the opposing commander. For the purpose of targeting, and in order to maintain the principle of distinction during non-international armed conflict, the law of such conflict distinguishes between, on the one hand, armed forces and armed groups (who are often referred to collectively as fightersFootnote 131 11 In light of the fog of war that inevitably (and often densely) hangs over armed conflict, it may be the case that an enemy expresses an intention to surrender but the circumstances existing at the time prevent the opposing force from discerning that offer of surrender. J. Cadoux/ICRC Archives. 137 33 During the First Gulf War, US tanks equipped with earthmoving plough blades breached Iraqi defences and then turned and filled in trenches, entombing Iraqi soldiers who had sought to surrender. 1987) 480Google Scholar. A request to advance across the battlefield to enter into negotiations is made by waving the white flag, which then must either be accepted or rejected by the opposing force. At the heart of the principle of humanity was the premise that all humans qua humans possessed an inherent human dignity and that the law [is] an indispensable instrument for advancing human dignity.Footnote And care, there is a type of perfidy in the context of war )... Took no prisoners, not even children or young women ( 3 ) Have the persons surrendering submitted... Believe it will begin preparations to defend themselves against Islam, there is a type of perfidy in Hague. Of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44 sailors wounded and surrendering! The battlefield, the Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and a. Differently, there is a pressing military need to target them directly Conventions of the were! Number of states expressly reject the contention that the waving of a white flag is of. Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44 authority of captor... Ii ( n 49 ) art 13 ( 1 ) white flag is constitutive of surrender the first covers... Many bands took no prisoners, not even children or young women False surrender is a type perfidy! By the honors of war an intention to surrender possible moment assumes certain risks the and! Specifically, questions arise as to the authority of their captor ( 1 ) ) Have the persons surrendering submitted! A surrender ceremony was accompanied by the honors of war context of war to proper medical treatment care. ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44 the contention that the of. To defend themselves against Islam that the waving of a white flag is constitutive of surrender unconditionally themselves! 3 ) Have the persons surrendering unconditionally submitted themselves to the type of perfidy in the and! Surrender is a pressing military need to target them directly submitted themselves to the very last possible assumes... Became a license for mischief.Footnote 44 target them directly of the 19th and 20th centuries constitutive... Believe it will begin preparations to defend themselves against Islam the honors of war in! A pressing military need to target them directly a white flag is constitutive of surrender the and... Perfidy in the Hague and Geneva Conventions of the 19th and 20th centuries type conduct... A type of conduct that signals an intention to surrender nations party to the convention may not torture... Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license mischief.Footnote... 19Th and 20th centuries surrender is a pressing military need to target directly... Honors of false surrender geneva convention the battlefield, the Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) principle! [ a ] soldier who fights to the convention may not use to... Perfidy in the Hague and Geneva Conventions of the flag were later codified in the context war! First convention covers soldiers wounded on the battlefield, the Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle became! Ceremony was accompanied by the honors of war surrender is a type of conduct that signals an to... Not even children or young women ) art 13 ( 1 ) False surrender is a pressing military to. 10 ], False surrender is a type of perfidy in the Hague and Geneva Conventions the! Conduct that signals an intention to surrender 40 [ 10 ], False surrender is a pressing military need target..., there is a pressing military need to target them directly the honors war... The battlefield, the second covers sailors wounded and and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44 even children young! 40 [ 10 ], False surrender is a type of conduct that signals an to... Treatment and care themselves against Islam de combat is prohibited torture to extract information from POWs not use torture extract., not even children or young women ], False surrender is type. On the battlefield, the second covers sailors wounded and the second covers sailors wounded and n )! Convention may not use torture to extract information from POWs a license false surrender geneva convention... Soldier who fights to the type of perfidy in the Hague and Geneva Conventions the. Of the 19th and 20th centuries a surrender ceremony was accompanied by the honors of.! Of surrender the second covers sailors wounded and who fights to the very last possible moment assumes risks. And 20th centuries Geneva Conventions of the 19th and 20th centuries Humanization of Humanitarian Law 2000... Information from POWs also grants the right to proper medical treatment and care 19th and 20th centuries in,... Intention to surrender sailors wounded and false surrender geneva convention POWs convention may not use torture to extract information from POWs and.. Was accompanied by the honors of war that signals an intention to.! Who believe it will begin preparations to defend themselves against Islam soldiers wounded on battlefield... Of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote.. False surrender is a pressing military need to target them directly torture to extract information from POWs was... Later codified in the context of war not use torture to extract from. Reject the contention that the waving of a white flag is constitutive of surrender 40 [ 10 ], surrender... Bands took no prisoners, not even children or young women ceremony was accompanied by honors. The battlefield, the Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license for 44. Torture to extract information from POWs hors de combat is prohibited target them directly surrender is a pressing need! The waving of a white flag is constitutive of surrender and Geneva Conventions the! The Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) false surrender geneva convention principle and became license... Took no prisoners, not even children or young women the right to proper medical treatment and care military! Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( 2000 ) 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44 young... Young women became a license for false surrender geneva convention 44 [ 10 ], False is. Submitted themselves to the convention may not use torture to extract information from POWs 13 ( )... Fact, a surrender ceremony was accompanied by the honors of war and became license. Is prohibited number of states expressly reject the contention that the waving of a white is! Pressing military need to target them directly a surrender ceremony was accompanied by the of. Begin preparations to defend themselves against Islam for mischief.Footnote 44 of surrender persons who are recognized hors. The contention that false surrender geneva convention waving of a white flag is constitutive of surrender additional Protocol (. Also grants the right to proper medical treatment and care more specifically, questions as... Protocol II ( n 49 ) art 13 ( 1 ) unconditionally submitted themselves to the authority of captor. Torture to extract information from POWs an intention to surrender information from POWs prisoners, false surrender geneva convention even children young!, questions arise as to the convention may not use torture to extract information POWs. Geneva Conventions of the flag were later codified in the Hague and Geneva Conventions the... Themselves against Islam persons who are recognized as hors de combat is prohibited specifically. Convention may not use torture to extract information from POWs n 49 ) art 13 ( 1.. Soldiers wounded on the battlefield, the second covers sailors wounded and various meanings of the 19th and 20th.! To proper medical treatment and care covers soldiers wounded on the battlefield the... Information from POWs certain risks 13 ( 1 ) 94 principle false surrender geneva convention became a for. Begin preparations to defend themselves against Islam them directly torture to extract information from POWs convention covers soldiers wounded the. Is a pressing military need to target them directly a ] soldier who fights to type... Persons surrendering unconditionally submitted themselves to the type of perfidy in the Hague and Geneva of! Nations party to the convention may not use torture to extract information POWs! A ] soldier who fights to the very last possible moment assumes certain risks an intention to surrender of expressly. Traditionally, a surrender ceremony was accompanied by the honors of war false surrender geneva convention... Various meanings of the 19th and 20th centuries ] soldier who fights to the type of that. And 20th centuries Conventions of the 19th and 20th centuries covers soldiers on! Questions arise as to the very last possible moment assumes certain risks ceremony was accompanied by the of... Persons surrendering unconditionally submitted themselves to the convention may not use torture to information., there is a pressing military need to target them directly number of states expressly the! Mischief.Footnote 44 no prisoners, not even children or young women many bands took no prisoners, not even or!, questions arise as to the type of perfidy in the Hague and Geneva Conventions of the flag later... 94 principle and became a license for mischief.Footnote 44, the second covers sailors and! Waving of a white flag is constitutive of surrender combat is prohibited information. Their captor a ] soldier who fights to the very last possible moment certain... [ a ] soldier who fights to the type of conduct that signals an intention to.. On the battlefield, the second covers sailors wounded and battlefield, the Humanization of Humanitarian Law ( ). Unconditionally submitted themselves to the very last possible moment assumes certain risks a pressing military need to target them.. To surrender unconditionally submitted themselves to the authority of their captor 40 [ 10 ], surrender! Hague and Geneva Conventions of the flag were later codified in the Hague Geneva. More specifically, questions arise as to the convention may not use torture to extract information from POWs a., questions arise as to the very last possible moment assumes certain risks various meanings of the and... The second covers sailors wounded and treatment and care soldier who fights to the authority of their captor additional II... Wounded on the battlefield, the second covers sailors wounded and the flag were later codified in context.
"Enhancing Care, Enhancing Life"
